Attentive. Smart. Conscientious.

Attorneys Amy M. McKinlay and Kerry E. Hageman-Froelich

Dividing luxury real estate in high asset divorces

On Behalf of | Mar 17, 2026 | Asset Division

Owning a vacation home, rental property, or commercial real estate can make divorce more complicated. These high-value assets often carry both financial and emotional weight. You may find yourself weighing how to keep a beloved vacation home while making sure both parties receive a fair share. Understanding what factors influence property division can help you approach the process with more clarity and confidence.

What counts as marital property

Courts do not automatically divide every piece of real estate in a divorce. In Ohio, the court looks closely at whether a property is marital or separate. 

Marital property usually means things you bought or gained together during the marriage. Separate property generally includes things you owned before the marriage or received as gifts or inheritance.

However, using marital funds to improve or maintain these properties can change how they are classified. Tracking down payments, mortgage contributions and major renovations can show how a property may be treated. 

Getting an experienced eye on the situation can help sort out which properties could be part of the division and the best way to explain that to the other side or a judge.

Splitting high-value properties

Once you know which properties count as marital, the next step is figuring out how to divide them. Now, Ohio follows equitable distribution. This means the court aims for a fair split of marital property rather than an automatic 50/50 division. Handling vacation homes, rentals or commercial properties often requires balancing financial, tax and personal considerations. 

Some approaches include:

  • Buying out your spouse’s share by using cash, other assets, or structured payments
  • Selling the property and splitting proceeds, which can trigger tax consequences for rental or investment properties
  • Trading the property for other assets, letting one spouse keep the property while balancing the division of other marital assets
  • Maintaining joint ownership temporarily, providing time to plan a future sale or refinance

Looking at these options together can help protect the property’s value and reduce stress. Consulting with a real estate appraiser or financial advisor may also clarify which strategy best aligns with your goals.

Finding your balance

Dividing luxury real estate can tie together memories, investments and lifestyle. Navigating its division often feels like adjusting pieces of a puzzle while keeping the bigger picture in view. Careful planning, clear records and informed decisions can help turn a complicated process into a balanced outcome that respects both financial and personal priorities.